| England Isthmian Division One South | 2023/12/26 13:00 | Merstham v Three Bridges | W | 3-2 |
| Club Friendly List | 2023/08/01 18:45 | Merstham v Chertsey Town | L | 1-3 |
| Club Friendly List | 2023/07/12 18:45 | Sutton Common Rovers v Merstham | L | 5-1 |
| England Isthmian Division One South | 2023/04/04 18:45 | Leatherhead v Merstham | L | 2-1 |
| England Isthmian Division One South | 2023/02/27 19:45 | Merstham v Chipstead | W | 1-0 |
| England Isthmian Division One South | 2023/02/20 19:45 | Merstham v Tooting & Mitcham Utd | D | 0-0 |
| England Isthmian Division One South | 2023/01/09 19:45 | Merstham v Sutton Common Rovers | W | 3-0 |
| England Isthmian Cup | 2022/10/31 19:45 | Merstham v Chatham Town | L | 0-3 |
| England Isthmian Division One South | 2024/04/16 18:30 | Burgess Hill Town v Sheppey Utd | W | 1-2 |
| England Isthmian Division One South | 2024/03/30 15:00 | Phoenix Sports v Sheppey Utd | L | 3-1 |
| England Isthmian Division One South | 2023/12/16 15:00 | Lancing v Sheppey Utd | W | 1-2 |
| England Isthmian Division One South | 2023/11/21 19:45 | Three Bridges v Sheppey Utd | L | 6-0 |
| England FA Cup | 2023/11/03 19:45 | Sheppey Utd v Walsall | L | 1-4 |
| England FA Cup Qualification | 2023/10/17 18:45 | Sheppey Utd v Billericay Town | D | 1-1 |
| England FA Cup Qualification | 2023/10/14 14:00 | Billericay Town v Sheppey Utd | D | 1-1 |
| England FA Trophy | 2023/10/07 14:00 | Ramsgate v Sheppey Utd | L | 4-1 |